Rehfuss played collegiately at Loyola (Md.) where she was a two-time captain. She finished her career with 177 points (127g, 50a) and ranks fourth all-time on the Greyhounds’ career draw controls list with 153. Rehfuss, who started all 71 games in which she played in the midfield, also recorded 107 ground balls and 65 caused turnovers.
The Latham, New York native earned All-BIG EAST Conference and Intercollegiate Women’s Lacrosse Coaches Association (IWLCA) All-Mid-Atlantic Region honors and was a 2011 IWLCA second-team All-American and Tewaaraton Award Watch List candidate. She also played professionally in the United Women’s Lacrosse League for the Philadelphia Force and the Boston Storm.
Rehfuss earned her bachelor’s degree in interdisciplinary writing and philosophy from Loyola in 2011 and her J.D. from Albany Law School in 2014. She has served as an attorney at The Rehfuss Law Firm, P.C. since 2015. Rehfuss was inducted into Shaker High School’s Hall of Fame in 2015 and the Empire North Lacrosse Association Hall of Fame in October of 2021. Rehfuss’ brother, Stephen, was an All-American attackman who played on the Orange men’s lacrosse team from 2017-21. He earned Syracuse Athletics’ highest honor, the Doris Soladay Award, in 2020, and was named captain and Syracuse’s Male Athlete of the Year in 2021.
The Orange recorded an 18-3 record in 2023 and advanced to the NCAA Tournament semifinals for the second time in three years.