Marcus Holman thinks Utah could be the next Denver. Brian Holman just hopes it doesn’t become the next youth lacrosse dystopia.
Brian Holman, the architect of the University of Utah’s jubilant jump from club to NCAA Division I men’s lacrosse, relayed recent experiences he had recruiting at an all-star team tryout in Baltimore and then watching his niece’s 10-year-old son play. He once was native to this scene, but since moving away from the hotbed, his perspective has changed.
“I’m just looking at it differently right now,” Holman said. “These kids trudge on and off the field. There was no passion. The parents are miserable. The kids have no freedom of expression. They’re over-coached.”
Holman bemoaned how early recruiting drove the sport into a state of excess, fueling the growth of a cottage industry that turned youth players into commodities. When he left Baltimore in 2008 to become an assistant coach at the University of North Carolina, he could see the tide turning. He had coached his sons, Matthew and Marcus, and their friends in the local rec league and continued with the Baltimore Breakers club program.
“We went to two tournaments a summer and won them both. Then, for my kids, we’d put the stick down,” Holman said. “There’s inordinate unseen pressure in the lacrosse community that if I’m not playing for this team in the fall, Johnny won’t be on that team in the spring. Well, why is he playing in the fall anyway?”
Single-sport specialization, an unbalanced emphasis on playing games rather than teaching core skills and pay-to-play dynamics emerged as the college coaches began targeting prospects earlier in their development. Holman saw it firsthand, and hopes the NCAA’s recent adoption of legislation banning recruiting contact with prospective student-athletes before Sept. 1 of their junior year of high school will help stem the tide.
“That will help the dust settle some,” said Holman, whose two sons and daughter, Sydney, all played for North Carolina. “But it won’t be the end-all, be-all.”