Hours after St. Mary’s had beaten St. Paul’s in the MIAA tournament semifinals, 9-5, largely due to his 16-save dominance, Troutner got a call from Torpey, who had recruited him since his junior year. Troutner, who later made nine saves to help the Saints beat McDonogh for the MIAA crown, was hooked.
Troutner says he also weighed late offers from Loyola and Maryland, who each had used up scholarship room for the incoming class arriving in 2016 — which meant Troutner would need a year at prep school. He had visited Salisbury (Conn.) School.
“But I wanted to go to college right away,” says Troutner, who had been pursued by Bellarmine and Furman (now SoCon rivals) and Towson (too close to home). Before Torpey’s offer came, Troutner was considering taking the local junior college route to get to Division I.
How did it come to that for a goalie whose high-level talent revealed itself so quickly at High Point?
The short answer is, Troutner got caught in circumstances that have affected numerous players in the sport’s recent age of prevalent, early recruiting. He also was victimized in a strange way by the lopsided success of his summer club team, the Annapolis Hawks.
At St. Mary’s, Troutner was surrounded by talented classmates or others who were early Division I signees, some as early as their freshman years. That pool included Jake Carroway (Georgetown), Tommy Miller (Navy), Kevin Fox and Aleric Fyock (Penn State), Bryce Carrasco (Loyola), Timmy Hardy and Paul Egloff (Villanova), Sean Mooney (Towson) and Jack Andrews (UMBC).
Even faceoff specialist and classmate Alex Woodall, another former St. Mary’s teammate, committed to High Point earlier in his senior year. Woodall transferred to Towson following his freshman season.
The fact that Troutner did not start for the Saints varsity until his final two seasons — under head coach and former Virginia All-America and MLL star attackman Ben Rubeor — proved to be problematic for his recruitment.
“I was a young coach and I got him [Troutner] wrong. He should have started [as a sophomore],” Rubeor says. “I remember Tim would come out on Friday nights to watch the Bayhawks [Rubeor’s team then] practice [at Navy]. I’d shoot on him after practice and I’d have a harder time scoring on him than I’d had against time the pro goalies I’d just practiced with.
“I am so glad he has made everything out of the opportunity given to him,” Rubeor adds. “That kid is a leader in every sense of the word. In my opinion, he’s the most underrated player in college lacrosse.”
On a club team as dominant as the Hawks, who averaged barely one loss per season, routinely blew out opponents by halftime and crushed them in the faceoff game with Woodall at the X, it was hard for Troutner to stand out.
“I’d get [college coaches] come out to watch Timmy play, and they’d see him face one shot in a half, before we’d changed goalies,” says Dave Cottle, the Bayhawks general manager and former college coaching legend who spent years assisting Tim Troutner, Sr., and Matt Hogan coaching the Hawks.
“I never thought of Timmy as a late bloomer. I always thought he was good. But he wasn’t appreciated early,” adds Cottle, who advised the Troutner family to be patient going into Tim’s senior year at St. Mary’s. “Not many parents today would have stayed the course the way the Troutners did. It worked out really well.”
As Tim Troutner, Sr. remembers, while his son was dreaming early in high school of playing for Duke or North Carolina or Johns Hopkins or Navy, Tim, Jr. watched underclassmen at St. Mary’s — even the occasional eighth grader — verbally commit to Division I schools.
All along, the father was sure of what his son could provide. Tim, Jr. was a standout safety at St. Mary’s, where he could read receivers and quarterbacks accurately, and pick off passes as well as any defensive back in the MIAA and better than most. Those instincts informed his play in the goal years ago, and still do.
“[Tim, Jr.] knows where the ball is going to go before it happens,” says Tim, Sr. “I remember how he shined at the Under Armour tryouts as a junior. Dave Cottle and Matt Hogan really believed in Tim. He already had the talent and the toughness [to be a Division I goalie]. But we had to be patient.
“Tim has always shaken off the bruises [a goalie gets]. I don’t think I’ve ever seen him cry. He never talked about being nervous [with recruiting anxiety]. He never felt the pressure. He just kept doing his job.”
“I’ve always tried to focus on what was right in front of me,” Troutner, Jr. says. “I’m still not fully developed as a goalie. When I got here, I had a terrible stance. I was a third-stringer the whole fall, thought I was going to red-shirt that year.
“But things have worked out. I look at so many relationships I’ve got with my teammates and coaches that I’ll always value. I look back on my decision [to come to High Point] with no regrets.”