“I wanted the guys to realize that yes, we were going to play Maryland, and we might win and we might lose, but there are things that are bigger than that,” he says. “I felt like I needed to tell them.”
“I didn’t know about it before he told us,” Vardaro says. “His story touched everyone. There were definitely tears when he was done.”
The same phone that has the old message from John Tillman also has another voicemail. This one does not make Ellis smile. On the night of Aug. 31, 2016, Ellis went to sleep in his room at Stony Brook. At 1:33 a.m. on Sept. 1, his phone rang. He slept through it.
When he woke up, he saw he had a voicemail from an unknown number. The message was soul-crushing.
Ellis has had his phone in his hands the entire time he has been sitting on the bench. He has gone back and pulled out a few pictures, some of his family. He’s shown a picture of his murdered cousin Melissa. Now he again goes into his phone, this time to play the voicemail.
It starts out as the voice identifies himself as a detective with the Nassau County police department. It goes on to say that his younger brother Corey has been arrested, and they were trying to reach his father. Corey didn’t know his dad’s number. He did know Ellis’.
“It’s crazy,” Ellis says after the message trails off. “We have the same parents. The same background. I told Corey he had two routes to choose from me. He could follow me to college. He could end up incarcerated. He chose the worst evil.”
Corey, whose last name is Williams, was alleged to be part of a series of violent crimes in Nassau County that spanned nearly a year. Included in that spree were two murders.
The legal process took a major toll on Ellis. The most heart-wrenching was when he saw the tape of his brother in the interrogation room, calling out for him. The trial would last four weeks, and the jury would deliberate for nearly a day before convicting him on all 17 charges, including two counts of second-degree murder.
He was sentenced to 100 years to life in prison. He was 19 years old at the time. He is currently serving his time in Attica State Prison in upstate New York.
“He ended up in a bad environment, with idiotic, no-mentorship situations,” Ellis says. “I wasn’t there for him. I was at school. People hate when I say that, but I feel like I let him down. My brother means a lot to me, but lives were taken, and you have to pay for that. It’s hard for me to think that I’ll never see him again outside of those walls.”
That’s part of the story that Ellis told the men’s lacrosse team.
“That story was incredibly touching,” Lazzaretto says. “That’s something none of us knew, but we all really felt it when he said it all.”
“I never knew that about Coach Ellis,” White says. “Hearing that story really gave me a new perspective on the hardships that have surrounded him throughout his life and how he’s become so successful despite them. I think this story is more powerful because of the fact that his brother is around our age. Coach Ellis was able to connect with us so well because he wishes his brother was able to be here and do something like this, but instead we have taken that place in his life.”
As Princeton’s season went along, Ellis had been keeping Corey updated. As the games got more dramatic, Corey’s interest grew.
“He wouldn’t ask me how I was doing,” Ellis says. “He’d go right to asking me about how the team was doing. I’d send him pictures. I’d send him clips. He’s the same age as the guys on the team. I wanted them to know that there were people they didn’t know who were rooting for them. It was a vulnerable spot for me, but I felt like I had to tell them.”
The other part of the story was about family. It was, as White said, about how he has found another family with the people in the locker room.
“It was an incredible moment,” Madalon says. “He’s an amazing person. He’s persevered through so much, and he still has such a great outlook about everything. He really touched everyone on our team.”
“We always talk about the aspect of family,” Vardaro says. “Coach Madalon always says it’s ‘we,’ not ‘I.’ We do things as a unit. This is a team sport. In the case of Coach Ellis, he embodies the brotherhood we try to create with Princeton men’s lacrosse. He really is a great man.”
ELLIS PULLS OUT HIS PHONE AGAIN and shows a few pictures of Corey. He’s seen him outside of the prison once, when Corey’s grandmother passed away and he was allowed to go to the funeral. The hurt is obvious when Ellis talks about his brother. The waste.
So, too, is the determination that has brought him from, as he said, the same background as his brother all the way to this bench on the Princeton campus.
“I was nervous when I first walked into this,” he says. “If you looked at the rest of my family minus me, you’d say there was no way I’d ever work at a place like Princeton. For me, I can bring them something different. I can tell them about my brother. It doesn’t matter about your background. People see me, and they don’t necessarily think ‘Princeton’ when they do. ‘You coach at Princeton?’ they say. ‘You’re not Princeton material.’ I was the only Black kid on any team I was on in high school. I can bring some light to the guys. These are some issues they’ve never had to deal with. I can’t blame them for not knowing what they don’t know. But maybe they think, ‘If this is something that Coach Ellis, who cares so much about me, deals with, then maybe I need to step back and consider things.’ I was worried when I came here that I would be dealing with a different kind of kid, but they’re not much different than the kids at Stony Brook and Hofstra that I played with. The academics are tougher. They ask a lot more questions, that’s for sure. If they don’t know something, they’re going to ask. I like that. I like the idea that I can teach them something they don’t know to guys who know a lot.”
He had thought about possibly going into coaching or athletic training, but the strength coach at Hofstra suggested Ellis would be good at what he did.
“I love to see the athletes progress,” he says. “I love to see it click in their heads. ‘Coach Ellis taught me this.’ I know what it takes to do it now. Yes, I’m coaching, but the athlete controls his or her fate. Sometimes they get lost. They just want to push and push and push. They want to see the reward. It’s perfect for a school like Princeton, where everyone is so intelligent. They see the numbers. They see the progression. They see where they are in the pecking order without having to have it be subjective. Are you slowest kid? Now we can fix that. They can see progress. They can see it. I love helping them get there.”
His vehicle for all of this is the weight room, that place of no BS. It fits him. There’s no BS to him either. He wants to grow in the position, eventually to run his own department.
Mark Ellis will stay true to himself. That you don’t have to worry about. He talks about how his mother never had to worry about him, how self-reliant he’s always been.
When he talks about wanting to make his family proud, he means the one he grew up in. He has two families now, though. That one, to whom he is still strongly connected, especially to the brother with whom all future contact will be on the other side of that horrific wall.
To that he has added the Princeton family.
“He’s as much a part of us as anyone,” Madalon says. “And we couldn’t be more thrilled about that.”
“I want to be able to impact people,” Ellis says. “This may sound naive, but I want to impact people in a way that will stay with them. I want to be part of a culture where the kids I work with come back and say, ‘This was the best experience of my life.’ I want them to see me after all those years and say, ‘You had a big impact on my life.’”
Then he gets up from the bench and heads towards Jadwin Gym, back to work. There’s only one thought to be had as you see him walk away.
Doesn’t he realize he already has?
This story was originally published by Princeton Athletics and is being republished with permission from the university.