***
Facing Towson on Feb. 4, Murphy had broken metacarpals in her left hand. It was a season-opening 10-9 win for the Seawolves, but it was her first injury in her lacrosse career.
Taking a step back was not an option according to Murphy, who had set the NCAA Division I women’s lacrosse single-season record with 100 goals in 2016.
Donning a red cast, she went on to play against Bryant one week later.
Then on March 5, in their second Top 20 win of the season against then-No. 12 Northwestern, a deafening scream silenced Kenneth P. LaValle Stadium. With just 10 seconds remaining in the first half, Murphy had hit the turf with a torn ACL.
“Mentally, just like anyone when you find out your season is pretty much done, it’s not a happy time,” Stony Brook women’s lacrosse trainer Barbara-Jean “BJ” Ercolino said. “It’s not one of those things we like to tell any of the athletes, but unfortunately it happens.”
Murphy was a senior.
She had her eyes set on reaching new heights after being on the cover of US Lacrosse Magazine in its annual college preview edition with Seawolves’ Tewaaraton finalist Kylie Ohlmiller, who broke a Division I single-season record with 164 points.
Murphy also already secured a job upon graduation at BTIG, a stockbroker company in New York City.
Her options, though simple, were hard to consider.
Murphy could either continue as planned – graduate and work on Wall Street like her brother, Steve, who played at Notre Dame – or redshirt and come back for a fifth season.
“She asked me what I thought,” Spallina said. “I said, flat out, ‘I think you know how I feel about you, but I also know that I would be doing an injustice if I tried to persuade you to come back.
“‘It’s something you have to want for yourself,’” he continued to tell her. “You’ve had an incredible career if you wrapped it up right now. But at the same token, it also would be nice to write your own ending, as opposed to it being written for you.”
It didn’t take long to make a decision.
“I just realized I don’t want it to end like this,” Murphy said. “[My family] realized where my heart really was.”
***
It took a trip to Gainesville, Fla., for the Seawolves’ March 11 game against Florida to put everything into perspective.
Just one day prior, the Stony Brook family had lost 19-year-old softball star Danni Kemp to a brain tumor.
Murphy then watched her team fall to the Gators, 22-14.
“[Danni] was one of us,” Murphy said. “We found out when we landed in Florida. It hit us really hard. The proximity of her [death] and my injury was definitely inspiring. The timing was insane. It was something that helped me push myself still to this day thinking about her and her battle.”
The Seawolves' loss to Florida was just one of two for the entire year, but Murphy needed it.
Watching the game from the sidelines, she “morphed into a very good assistant coach,” said Spallina, who clearly recalled the Gators subbing all 12 players after a goal as if it was “choreographed across the 50-yard line.”
It was in that moment that Murphy grabbed his arm, spun him around, and told him she was coming back.
“That probably helped plant the seed for her to come back,” Spallina said. “The way the Florida game played out confirmed her gut.”
With an impending winter storm in New York, Spallina paid for Murphy to fly home early for her March 15 surgery.
As predicted, her coach and teammates got stuck in Florida following its March 13 game against Jacksonville. Therefore, the rest of the Spallina family – wife Mary Beth and their five children, whom Murphy regularly babysits – joined Murphy’s parents in the hospital for the moment she woke up.
“She’s part of the fabric of our program and my family,” Spallina said. “You can say you care, but show you care.”
“It’s nice to know I have a second family here,” Murphy said. “They’re always behind me.”