As for comparisons with Kerrigan Miller, their games are more different than they are similar. Kerrigan Miller “runs hot” with energy and desire, Gick said. Maddigan Miller has the same will to win, but Gick said she’s “as cool as ice.”
Where they are similar is in their ability to lead teammates – something the younger Miller takes pride in doing.
“Kerrigan is awesome. Even at home, she’s the same person all the time,” she said. “I think growing up with her, she was the next oldest from me, so she was my role model my whole life. Just seeing her leadership and positivity affect other players and how well they responded to her definitely helped shape me into the leader that I am today.”
That leadership was on full display in the Long Island Class C championship game, with Bayport-Blue Point trailing Manhasset (N.Y.) during a hydration break midway through the second half.
It was the same stage she reached as a sophomore when the Phantoms lost to Cold Spring Harbor by one goal.
“That bus ride home was one of the worst memories,” she said. “You feel that, and you just never want to feel that again.”
In that moment during the break, Miller pulled her teammates together, almost shaking with emotion and choking back tears, and gave an impassioned plea.
“I told my team, ‘We cannot lose right now,’” she said. “I literally said, ‘They cannot score another goal. Every mistake from this point matters.’”
Bayport-Blue Point rallied to win the Long Island championship game 6-5 and finished the season 17-0.
“It was just a huge relief,” Miller said. “I bawled my eyes out. It was happy tears, but also it was my last high school lacrosse game. It’s so surreal. The whole team was so close this year. There was never any drama.”
In addition to her three older sisters, Miller’s cousin Joe Miller is the faceoff specialist at Navy. Another cousin, Ailish Kelly, is about to be her Stanford teammate, and Kelly’s older sister plays for the Coast Guard.
“One year for Thanksgiving, we rented out a turf field and played a huge game,” Millerr said. “I was probably 4 years old.”
Around the same time, whenever oldest sibling MacKenzie Miller wanted to get in some extra work while babysitting, she’d take her sister out to the front yard and have her pass the ball.
“It was always fun, never pushed upon us, and my sisters made it fun to hang out with them and make it family bonding,” Maddigan Miller said.
As much as Miller will miss her high school experience — one cut short because the COVID-19 pandemic shut down her junior year — she said she can’t wait for the next step, joining Ailish Kelly and her best friend Erin Schaefer at Stanford.
“It is sad to move on to the next chapter, but I’m ready,” Miller said. “I’m excited to see what will go on at Stanford. It is a little emotional, but at the same time super exciting. I’m ready.”