The Waterdogs trailed 4-1 late in the first quarter, as Chaos goalie Blaze Riorden made eight saves in the first 11 minutes. But the large, lively crowd that largely favored the Waterdogs came to life when Philadelphia area native Michael Sowers scored on a leaping putback with 25.4 seconds left.
Sowers’ goal ignited a four-goal run that carried into the second quarter. McArdle gave the Waterdogs their first lead when he got topside on Chaos defenseman Jarrod Neumann and hit Riorden with a shot that trickled in to make it 5-4 at the 6:42 mark, but Byrne evened the score less than two minutes later.
It was tied at 5 at halftime. Then came another four-goal flurry, with the Waterdogs midfield doing much of the damage despite missing Mikie Schlosser due to injury. Conrad scored twice from up top and Jack Hannah hit a near-pipe blast dodging across the arc, punctuating a run that put the Waterdogs ahead 9-5 with 6:16 left in the third quarter.
The Chaos refused to go quietly, however. A minute later, Riorden made a save and then quickly fed long-stick midfielder Matt Rees going the other way. Rees, who had the extra point taken off a 2-point goal in the first quarter after review, left nothing to chance. He unleashed a howitzer from a few feet beyond the arc and beat Ward to pull the Chaos back within two. Then Kyle Jackson scored to make it 9-8 going into the fourth quarter.
But the Chaos turned the ball over on four of their first five possessions in the fourth quarter and McArdle picked up a pair of fourth-quarter assists on goals by Ethan Walker and Connor Kelly to keep the Waterdogs ahead.
The Chaos also committed two penalties in the fourth quarter, notably a two-minute unsportsmanlike conduct penalty charged to Chase Fraser after he threw a punch at Waterdogs defenseman Chris Sabia following Sabia’s hard body check on Byrne in front of the goal. Sabia received one minute for his role in the ensuing fracas. The hit was not penalized.
“I don’t think I’ve ever coached a game where every call was spot-on perfect,” Chaos coach Andy Towers said. “I credit Chase Fraser for stepping up and supporting his teammate. Do I think Byrnsey got fouled? Sure I do.”
The Waterdogs did not attempt a shot during their one-minute man-up, settling instead for a shot clock violation and then leaning on Ward to seal the game late.
The Chaos put just 20 of 38 shots on goal and converted on nine of them.
“Dillon Ward is an incredible goalie, a great person and a good friend. But Dillon Ward didn’t beat us today. It’s that simple,” Byrnes said. “We beat ourselves. We were settling for good shots and not great shots. That’s part of our Canadian culture, getting dunks and not settling for those nine- or 10-yard shots.”
The Waterdogs were more efficient and balanced on offense. McArdle, a nine-year pro lacrosse veteran who had never won a championship at any level, led the way with four points on two goals and two assists. Conrad had a hat trick. Sowers, limited to a degree by an injury he sustained in the semifinals last week, and Kelly added two goals apiece.
Sowers was named the PLL championship MVP, much to the delight of his hometown crowd.
“You come out of Duke and there’s a lot of cameras in your face. He just handles it well. He keeps his poise. He keeps his calm,” McArdle said. “Some of the plays he makes, I wish I could move like that. Mikey is going to be a successful pro for a long time. I’m lucky enough to be his line mate.”
“He’s one of the best lacrosse players in the world, no doubt about it,” Copelan said of Sowers as the press conference neared its end. “He knew his limitations today, kept it simple and produced. This kid has a huge professional future.”
Ward quickly grabbed the mic from Copelan. “And he’s paying our bar tab tonight,” he quipped.
Party on, Waterdogs.