Paul Schimoler’s impact on the game started when he stepped foot on campus at Cornell. A freshman from Manhasset, N.Y. He was a heralded recruit that coach Richie Moran coveted, even though he had veteran goalies entering the season.
He enlisted help from players like Joe Lizzio and Michael DeStefano to make sure Schimoler enjoyed his visit.
“Hey guys, just relax,” he told them. “I’m coming here.”
And he stayed true to his word. He joined the Cornell program in 1985 and took the starting job almost immediately. He was a natural leader, barking out instructions to his defenders, many of whom were much older than him.
But it didn’t matter. Cornell quickly saw a goalie that let few shots past him, leading the Big Red to success throughout this career. He brought his best effort almost every day, whether it was practice or game.
“It was just hard as heck to score on him at practice,” said Cornell teammate Joe Lizzio. “When you’re going full field against him every day at practice, you remember the goals you scored on him. If you were fighting for a position and you scored on Paul, that was a big event for you.”
When Cornell took the field, opponents felt the same way. He won Ivy League Rookie of the Year in 1986 en route to becoming a four-time All-American. He made an NCAA record 787 saves in his career.
With Schimoler in the cage, Cornell made the NCAA championship game in 1987 and 1988, where it fell to Johns Hopkins and Syracuse in consecutive years. He set the NCAA tournament record with 85 saves in 1988, which still stands today. Schimoler was keeping offenses guessing.
On multiple occasions, he stood tall, enduring shots from greats like Gary and Paul Gait.