Davis-Allen, 25, might not be an extrovert in the sense that one owns the room or posts prolifically, but he strives to make meaningful personal connections in his every endeavor.
“He’s an old soul,” Phipps said. “A very mature kid that gets life.”
When Tillman’s mother, Elizabeth, died after a long battle with Parkinson’s disease in April 2017, IDA became an unlikely source of comfort. That Mother’s Day, on the morning of Maryland’s NCAA tournament opener against Bryant, Tillman awoke to a phone call from his senior captain.
“That was just Isaiah,” Tillman says. “‘Hey Coach, just checking in on you.’”
Mariano has come to appreciate Davis-Allen’s penchant for real talk.
“He’s not putting it on social media. He’s not hunting for his brand,” Mariano says. “He genuinely cares.”
Don’t mistake IDA for a softy, however. Part of what made him one of the most effective leaders Tillman says he has ever coached was a no-nonsense attitude that was sometimes jarring for younger teammates — the same approach that has allowed him to be so successful at Buch Construction, a general contractor in the cutthroat D.C. market.
“He’s got a job where there’s times he’s basically working 24 hours a day. He might be going to the job site at 3 a.m. because they’re delivering tile. He may have to fire a subcontractor that may try to fight him because he’s pissed and losing a ton of money,” Mariano said. “And we’re not talking about building houses. We’re talking about building commercial business projects — malls. He’s meeting with people, representing them in their COVID response and it’s a hundred million-dollar job. He’s very intense. He’s extremely competitive. He’s very driven.”
Phipps says Davis-Allen personifies the position he plays.
“He’s that bring-your-hardhat-to-work, lunch-pail kind of guy. Get your [stuff] done and move on. He doesn’t need accolades. It goes with that short-stick d-middie position,” Phipps says. “I remember last season he’d be working until 3 in the morning and showing up to the walkthrough [hours later].”
On his Harley, of course. Davis-Allen can’t help but be on the move.
“I’m just wired like that,” he says. “There’s so much time in the day.”
Spending up to 12 days in an Annapolis bubble should feel oddly confining for Davis-Allen, but focusing exclusively on lacrosse while playing in a format that caters to his talents could be the perfect recipe for his pro lacrosse breakthrough. Tillman says he’s “one of the best players at his position in the world.” Mariano says he “should be a superstar right now.”
Excellence, Davis-Allen says, is another family tradition. His mother went to Tufts and got her doctorate in neuropsychology at George Washington. His aunt went to business school at NYU. His grandfather owned a factory in New Jersey making airplane parts. His younger sister, Josie, 20, stopped playing soccer at DeSales so she could focus on nursing.
“If you’re going to do something in the Davis-Allen family,” he says, “you better be the best at it.”
Be the best. Where have we heard that before?
Because of our US Lacrosse members, US Lacrosse Magazine is able to deliver the best in-depth lacrosse news, features and more to our readers. Join or renew today to help support US Lacrosse and the positive development of our sport. Thank you for your support!