But it also ended with a painful memory for a team in a one-bid league.
“I already knew I was coming back, but when you’re watching someone else take the trophy right across from you, it kind of set that fire. I think that definitely set the tone for this season,” goalie Brendan Krebs said.
Krebs and Pacher, a first-team all-MAAC defenseman, are among six graduate students on Manhattan’s 38-man roster. Three of them — Pacher and midfielders Sean MacKinney and Jake Nicolosi — earned first-team all-Metro Atlantic nods.
Yet it isn’t a team with one transcendent star. Each of the Jaspers’ top four scorers has at least 21 goals and 33 points. Junior Kyle Gucwa leads in both categories with 30 goals and 39 points.
“We’ve just found ways to get it done as a group,” Kelleher said. “That’s a real testament to what these guys are all about, just finding a win. This year with this team, I’ve really enjoyed how they’ve put the team first. We don’t have a defensive player of the year or offensive player of the year. We just have a really strong team. Different guys are stepping up all the time.”
Never was that more apparent than Saturday, when goals were hard to come by against stingy St. Bonaventure goalie Brett Dobson. With the Bonnies’ defense difficult to break down, the only multi-goal scorer was attackman Justin Malpica.
The graduate student had three goals all season prior to the MAAC final, then he scored three times (including twice in the fourth quarter). It was his first hat trick since Feb. 20, 2018, the third game of his career.
“We talked last week at practice how in tournaments, a lot of times somebody comes out of nowhere and makes big plays,” Kelleher said. “For him to score three in the finals, I’m just so happy for him. He’s played really well. I’m really happy for Justin. He’s another fifth-year that’s pushed us over the top here.”
Manhattan needed a defensive stand in the final minute after the Bonnies closed within one, and the victory was sealed only after a shot to tie it sailed wide. Pacher figured he had to get matched up before realizing the significance of the moment.
“Then the horn blew, and I’m like, ‘Oh my God, I think we just won,’” Pacher said.
Krebs, who has known Pacher since kindergarten and played lacrosse with him from pee-wee leagues through their days at Long Island’s Chaminade High School and now at Manhattan, had a similar reaction.
“Coach and I were joking that we felt like the refs were going to come back out on the field and add more time on the clock,” Krebs said. “It was pretty cool. It’s a pretty surreal feeling. I don’t know if it’s set in yet. We still have more lacrosse to play, and I think that’s what we’re looking forward to.”
That starts against Vermont, which is making its second consecutive NCAA tournament appearance. The Jaspers’ only other NCAA berth resulted in a 12-7 first-round loss to Georgetown exactly 20 years ago Thursday.
The return trip took a while to secure, which makes the past few days something to appreciate all the more.
“As we’ve gone through, we’ve gotten better, and I think guys have gotten a taste of winning and they really like that more than anything else,” Pacher said. “Now it’s, ‘We want more of this. How can we get more of this?’ That’s really helped the program more than anything else.”