“He’s 5-foot-9 and plays a lot bigger with the contact that he initiates,” Sheehan said. “It was just getting him to understand that if you’re throwing your body around the way he was, it’s going to be tough to maintain. You don’t have to end up on the ground every time you dodge.”
McCreary brings the same intensity to practices.
“It’s a little creepy and weird,” McCreary said. “I had some of the best defensemen playing against me and after practice, my whole right shoulder would be black and blue. They’d be like, ‘Jesus, what’s that from?’ I’m like, ‘It was you.’ I loved it.”
Playing box lacrosse on the Onondaga Reservation as one of the few non-Native runners gave McCreary an edge. When he reached high school at Christian Brothers Academy, he bonded with then-coach Ric Beardsley, the former Syracuse great and one of the most electric personalities in the game. Together, they won the New York Class D championship in 2017, McCreary’s senior year. It was the Warriors’ first-ever state title.
“The more he gets hacked, the more he wants to play,” Beardsley said. “He’s sick in the head, a little bit. We would replace his jersey every year because it would get sliced.”
McCreary doesn’t need the ball in his stick to be successful. With Lindenwood transfer Carter Collins now in the fold, he won’t be the Dolphins’ sole initiator on offense. However, he’s just fine using his body and creating chaos.
He’ll do so wearing No. 12 in honor of his friend and late teammate Kaiden Tubbert, who died by suicide in March 2020. McCreary asked Tubbert’s parents for their permission.
“He’s there with me. He’s on my chest,” McCreary said. “It’s really special having him be a part of me. I know he’ll always be a special part of my life.”