If the Selection Committee has taught us anything over the years, it’s that the eye test doesn’t matter. Selection is driven by metrics.
For this exercise, let’s pick on Georgetown.
The 6-0 Hoyas enter the week as one of five remaining unbeaten teams in Division I. But Georgetown’s schedule holds up like yours truly in water … and I can’t swim.
Three of Georgetown’s wins have come against Lafayette (0-6), Towson (0-6) and Bellarmine (2-6). The Hoyas’ “best” wins to date are against UMBC (4-1) and Fairfield (4-2). But if you put your nose closer to the bowl, the flavor fades altogether.
Fairfield has feasted on the likes of Quinnipiac, LIU and Merrimack, the first year D-I program. Those teams are a combined 2-16. UMBC’s four wins are against Mount St Mary’s (3-4), Sacred Heart (1-5), Towson (0-6) and High Point (2-6).
Allow the Georgetown chorus a moment to yell across the Key Bridge.
“We’re 6-0! Have you watched us play?” or, “Hater. The author must have gone to Syracuse.”
Choose your own truth, but accept the reality that Georgetown has looked flat out dominant in its six wins. If you apply past as prologue, the Hoyas have won the Big East tournament two years in a row. Jake Carraway anchors a supremely talented offense. The defense has been stingy, and Kevin Warne’s one of the best coaches in America.
There’s one problem. None of that matters. The committee has shown time and again that “how you play” and “how you look” amounts to less than a hastily constructed pocket square.
Strength of schedule — or lack thereof — matters. Quality wins matter. Georgetown has neither of those. The reality is Penn (1-3) has a better at-large resume right now than Georgetown. The Hoyas’ at-large chances boil down to how they play in four games. It starts Saturday when Georgetown visits North Carolina. The Hoyas close out March with a home game against Denver. April offers two more chances with a mid-week tilt against Loyola (April 7) before a weekend tilt at a suddenly surging Villanova. If the Hoyas don’t make up enough ground in those games, it’s automatic qualifier or bust. Eye test be damned.
That’s why Denver’s road win at Notre Dame carries so much weight. The Pioneers had already lost to Duke and North Carolina. A Notre Dame loss would have given Denver almost no margin for error in league play. But the win against the Irish gives Bill Tierney’s squad a deposit slip for May. It could end up being the difference between having an at-large berth to fall back on or needing the AQ. It also gives teams like Villanova and Georgetown a bump should they beat Denver in league games.
It’s still March, but here’s some food for thought for the coming week:
What if Notre Dame Loses to Ohio State Tonight?
Notre Dame’s best win would be Richmond. Before you say, “the Spiders almost beat Maryland and Duke,” remember this: The committee will give you the Dr. Evil “zip it” treatment.
That doesn’t matter when it comes to selection. Richmond is a quality opponent and is the current favorite in the SoCon. But should Notre Dame fall to Ohio State, the Irish resume would lack “big wins” — at least for now.
What if Virginia Falls to Maryland This Weekend?
Despite a pair of stumbles to Princeton and Brown, the defending champ aces the eye test. It’s a roster loaded with talent, but what matters is who you beat. Virginia’s best wins would be Lehigh and Loyola. The Greyhounds’ track record and 4-2 record may tell you, “Hey that’s a solid win, right?” But look at who Loyola has beaten — Johns Hopkins (1-5), Rutgers (2-4), Towson (0-6) and Lafayette (0-6). Lehigh’s 5-1 record is buoyed by wins against second-year program Utah (3-3), VMI (0-4), NJIT (1-6), Navy (3-2) and Holy Cross (4-3). A win against the Terps would add needed polish to the resume.
What if UNC Falls to Georgetown?
The Big East would then look like a potential two- or three-bid league with Villanova, Denver and Georgetown all in the mix. Georgetown’s at-large chances improve exponentially as well, barring no surprising losses.
Meanwhile, ACC play now turns into a game of musical chairs. At the start of the season, it was reasonable to think everybody had a seat. Now, it’s almost certain one ACC team will get left out, and possibly more than one. Outside of a Denver win, North Carolina’s schedule strength doesn’t hold up. Duke also clings to a Denver win. The ACC counted on league games and league wins providing a lift to SOS and RPI, but that bounce is somewhat negated when those teams stumble in the key non-conference games that shape conference strength.
The Ivy League’s combined 9-2 record vs the ACC and Big Ten bode well for later in the season. Brown and Princeton took down Virginia. The Tigers also subdued Johns Hopkins and Rutgers. Penn dropped Duke. Cornell scored wins against Ohio State and Penn State. Yale owns wins against Penn State and Michigan. The Ivy League can legitimately send four teams to the NCAA tournament.
As we talked about a few weeks earlier, teams change and evolve with the season. That absolutely matters for when you get into league tournaments or the NCAA tournament. But getting in requires winning games while evolving, too. Most of us who cover the sport deal in qualitative analysis, but the committee almost strictly deals in quantitative absolutes. The numbers don’t always tell the whole story, but again, that doesn’t matter.