I was speaking to a young man from North Carolina who was asking for advice about being recruited. It would be fair to describe him as a late bloomer, someone who had a good junior year, from an emerging area and who now felt he had the ability to play at the next level. He wanted to know if he still had a chance to be recruited.
I told him that the second we hung up the phone, he needed to compile a list of his top schools and write a letter to each of the coaches at those institutions. Easy enough for computer-savvy prospects to personalize each one.
(Please have someone proofread the first one to each school. I can’t tell you how many letters start out with, “Coach Starsia, I am very interested in the University of Notre Dame!” It is not a deal breaker, but careless.)
Include some basic information – school, grades, test scores, high school coach, contact information for him, club team, summer schedule, name of your club coach and his contact information also. Try to avoid subjective descriptions like, “I’m very coachable,” or “I will be a hard worker.”
The first indication to me that you may not be coachable is that you think you are.
In addition, for someone who has only experienced the first few years of a high school career, I’m sorry, but you have no idea about hard work.
You can avoid these areas completely or, if you must, try, “I look forward to working with you and your staff” and/or “I would greatly look forward to being a member of your program.”
I am always much more interested in hearing about your high school football, basketball [and/or other sports’] exploits.
“Wow, this young man was really good in this high school summer lacrosse tournament I watched and he is the starting tailback for the high school football team.”
That would be a much more reliable indicator that you are the caliber of athlete to play at the next level. I might rather come watch you play football than another lacrosse tournament in the fall.
I tell parents all the time that the simplest way to determine whether your son can play at the highest-level Division I schools is to answer this question, “Is your son one of the best athletes at his high school, period?”
Include a highlight tape, if you have one. Three or four minutes is plenty long enough. Please consider who is listening when you pick out the accompanying music and put your best stuff at the beginning of the tape. I might not make it to the third minute if you haven’t gotten my attention pretty quickly.
While I have never seen this young man [from North Carolina] play, the answer to his question of whether he might still be recruited is answered with another question, “Are you good enough?”
If you/he are, there are still lots of good college opportunities out there.
Enjoy the rest of the summer.