By 2015, as Rutgers officially joined the Big Ten, the incoming class that included Rexrode, defenseman Alex Bronzo and attackman Jules Heningburg showed striking talent. It was clear to Brecht that freshmen would have something to say quickly about Rutgers’ immediate future.
The year produced a 5-10 record that was deceptive. Six losses were by one or two goals, including one-goal losses to third-ranked Maryland and 10th-ranked Princeton.
“There were some good moments, like the [season-ending, 17-10] win over Ohio State,” said Heningburg, the team’s second-leading scorer a year ago.
“But the culture was still kind of messed up – guys going out [late at night] when they shouldn’t have been going out. You’d think that everybody playing Division I lacrosse would do whatever they can do win, but that wasn’t the case. That really changed when Scott led us last year.”
By the time the 2016 season started, the Scarlet Knights had embraced and begun to execute their transition-fueled philosophy that had worked so effectively under Brecht at Siena. The all-in message truly had begun sink in. And leaders such as Bieda and senior long-stick midfielder Zack Sikora (seven goals, 10 points, team-high 45 ground balls) were showing the way.
The Scarlet Knights opened with a 7-2 start against nonconference competition, but fell against Princeton and Stony Brook by a combined 12 goals. But it was on April 2 in its Big Ten opener – a 16-9 stunner over visiting, ninth-ranked Hopkins – that Rutgers guaranteed just its eighth winning year in 25 seasons.
That victory would pale in comparison to the one on May 5, in the Big Ten tournament semifinals under the lights at Homewood. In a riveting contest that featured 10 ties and five lead changes, the Scarlet Knights had the last word with a 14-12 victory. They would lose two days later to top-seeded Maryland, but the foundation had been laid.
“Those games really fueled us for this year. We have the inner belt now,” said junior goalie Max Edelmann, who watched those Hopkins wins on the sideline last year, after going down with a serious abdominal injury in the season’s third game, before getting offseason surgery and reclaiming his job in 2017.
“Those wins over Hopkins opened our eyes to how good we are,” added Rexrode, who was drawing Division III interest before Rutgers made him an offer just before his senior year at Loudon County (Va.) High School. “We might not have the best recruits or athletes, but we out-hustled and out-worked that team.”
“Considering where we came from, that win [at Homewood] will go down as one of the most special days of my career,” Bieda said.
“What Brian has done is inject Rutgers with the same thing he had going at Siena. They know who they are and who they want to be, and they are identifying guys who fit their style,” Hopkins coach Dave Pietramala said. “Rutgers is a place that should be able to compete well in lacrosse and do it consistently.”
“I was thrilled for the senior class and our alumni,” said Brecht, reflecting on the tournament win at Homewood. “I also think that’s a wakeup call for the guys coming into the program.
“We’re developing trust and confidence in the way we want to play, and game day is becoming more about turning things over to the players. The expectations and standards are going up. The program is maturing.”