3. East Stroudsburg has a superstar.
Anyone that has followed D-II women’s lacrosse in 2024 (or any part of the past four years) knows that East Stroudsburg features one of the most dynamic players in the nation in midfielder Emily Mitarotonda. Adelphi saw her impact earlier this year, as Mitarotonda tallied seven goals, including the last four in regulation, to fuel ESU’s win over the Panthers.
The four-time All-American did more Mitarotonda things again in Saturday’s Atlantic Region final against West Chester, sparking ESU’s fourth-quarter rally from a four-goal deficit with two of her game-high four goals. Mitarotonda’s heroics handed West Chester its first loss of the year and lifted East Stroudsburg to its third Final Four appearance in four years.
West Chester coach Ginny Martino had a plain-and-simple explanation for East Stroudsburg’s comeback. “Emily Mitarotonda won the game for them in the fourth quarter,” she said.
Mitarotonda finished with four goals and four assists, having a hand in eight of ESU's 13 markers on the day. She also added team highs with four ground balls, six caused turnovers and three draw controls. The senior has 95 goals this season, a new Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference record, and now 311 career goals, second all-time in NCAA Division II history.
“Emily proved today why she is the nation’s best player, in my opinion,” ESU coach Xeni Barakos-Yoder said. “She makes plays at both ends of the field, and her defensive play, really, is what brought us back into this game.”
Beyond her on-field exploits, Mitarotonda has also assumed a larger leadership role in 2024, displaying a more vocal presence with her teammates.
“I yell at them to get them fired up,” Mitarotonda said. “They know it’s because I care. I just have so much trust in this team. The vibes are good.”
4. Don’t sleep on Tampa and Regis.
While Tampa is the only first-timer among this year’s semifinalists, the Spartans are a legit contender, confirmed by 11 wins this season over ranked opponents, including two road wins at Florida Southern. Fueled by an offense that features four 40-goal scorers and a defense anchored by All-American goalie Alex Walling, this battle-tested squad has won 15 of its last 16 games and brings a nine-game winning streak into Thursday.
“I think we’re playing our best at the right time of the year,” said Tampa coach Kelly Gallagher, now in her 11th year leading the Spartans. “We’re playing with a lot of confidence, and it’s really awesome to see how the players have locked in to what we do. We’re having a lot of fun.”
Similarly, Regis is also a team on a roll, pushing its winning streak to 16 games following back-to-back one-goal thrillers over Grand Valley State and Maryville in the Midwest Regional. The only blemish all season was a loss to Maryville in mid-March, which the Rangers avenged with Saturday’s victory. Regis returns to the national semifinals for the third time, and the first since going back-to-back in 2018 and 2019.
“There’s a tremendous amount of talent on this team, but truthfully, sometimes we battle confidence,” Regis coach Sarah Kellner said. “But I believe in this team. It’s a resilient group with a lot of heart. We’re ecstatic to still be playing.”
Regis has won both prior meetings against Tampa, with a pair of one-goal victories in 2019 and 2022.
5. A gathering spot for All-Americans.
There will be no shortage of All-America talent at Showalter Stadium this weekend, with 10 players across the four semifinalists' rosters who were named to last week's USA Lacrosse All-America teams. The midfield position is especially well-stocked in great players, from ESU's Mitarotonda (first team) to Adelphi's duo of Kerrin Heuser and Kelly-Ann McGrath (both second team), and from Regis' Bailey Truex (second team) and Maggie Schipfer (third team) to Tampa's CeCe Colombo.