Death, taxes and squabbling over the final few teams — the certainty of life.
It’s Selection Sunday, and this year’s 29-team field will elicit many feelings. There are major discussions about the bottom three seeds and for the final at-large berths in the field. What will the committee do?
As we’ve mentioned before, the quality of winning is very important. Most people, even this bracketologist, were surprised to see Florida garner a No. 6 seed in a committee projection just two weeks ago ahead of two teams that it lost to, Stony Brook and Loyola.
Since then, all three teams have been undefeated and Florida’s RPI has jumped to No. 5, while Stony Brook’s has slipped to No. 8 and Loyola crept to No. 10. Head-to-head is just one of five primary criteria to rank teams. In this case, Florida’s superior RPI, strength of schedule and record against common opponents are already data points to keep the Gators ahead. Despite the head-to-head results, its win over Syracuse has carried weight with the committee before, and it’s safe to assume it will continue to do so.
Enter Rutgers, which just dismantled Northwestern in the Big Ten semifinals on Friday night. The Scarlet Knights have the No. 7 RPI and now have a marquee win that’s even better than Florida’s. It’s right to place them as the national No. 6 seed, thus Stony Brook or Loyola will be left out.
SBU has been getting the nod thanks to a superior RPI (No. 8 vs. No. 10), strength of schedule (No. 22 vs. No. 27) and additional wins over teams likely to be in the NCAA field (Arizona State, and now newly minted America East champion, Vermont).
Down the ladder, our final four teams in the field include Arizona State, Michigan, UConn and Johns Hopkins. Each have their pros and cons.
The first six we have left out (in order) are UMass, Vanderbilt, Ohio State, Virginia Tech, Navy and Temple. The main reasons for this order are similar themes to how we seeded the top eight teams: better RPI, SOS and better wins, as well as record against common opponents and head-to-head results.
In this range, managing significant losses becomes a factor, which is why Vanderbilt, Ohio State, Virginia Tech, Temple and even Colorado, which has a massive win over Denver, will suffer — all carry losses to teams out of the field and with RPIs above 40.
Arizona State (RPI No. 27) will be the team with the lowest RPI in our final projection. ASU beat tourney teams Rutgers, USC and Stanford. Michigan’s early season win over Notre Dame is valuable, as are victories over ASU and Johns Hopkins.
No one will argue that UConn’s blowout losses are something to be concerned about. The results are bad, but the bubble is weak without many bid thieves. Ultimately, it’s a season of work, not just recent results.
UConn and UMass have just one opponent in common, both victories over UMass Lowell. UConn has a better RPI (No. 14 vs. No. 20) and won the head-to-head matchup, while UMass has a slightly better SOS (No. 44 vs. No. 47). Fairfield’s win today also put a tournament team on UConn’s ledger.
Johns Hopkins is an even trickier case. JHU and UMass didn’t play a single common opponent and didn’t play each other, but Hopkins has a better RPI (No. 15 vs. No. 19) and SOS (No. 9 vs. No. 45). The Blue Jays’ best wins are over Ohio State and Penn State, both top 30 teams, and Drexel’s win today put a tourney team on their resume as well.
UMass has Saint Joseph’s and Vermont as tourney winners on its schedule, but neither of those teams are close to being in the field as at-large teams. With that said, it shouldn’t surprise if UMass gets in over Hopkins. None of its three losses were to non-tournament teams.
Vanderbilt’s early season win over Notre Dame will get the Commodores close, but losses to Colorado and Louisville dragged down their RPI and will count as significant losses. Ohio State misses out despite a win over Michigan, but a loss to Colorado wipes out that positivity, as does a head-to-head loss to Hopkins.
And the final puzzle — bracketing and travel. Some of the non-seeding teams didn’t stray too far from what would be expected, except for the case of the midwestern pod of Northwestern, Central Michigan, Notre Dame and Michigan.
Nevertheless, there will be a decent number of flights. Three Pac-12 teams are in our projected field along with Denver, so at least four teams will need to fly.
A major issue of bracket integrity popped up because Duke had limited options to travel. We have the Blue Devils ranked No. 10. The committee usually goes out of its way to protect the top two or three seeds, thus shipping them to North Carolina or Maryland seems unlikely, even if it saves money. Duke can’t drive to the other pods, so we kept their line intact and have them flying to No. 7 seed Florida to face Jacksonville.
NOTES
-
Records against the top 20, top 21-40, significant wins and significant losses (41st or higher) are based on performance against the current RPI rankings (as of Monday, April 25), not human polls.
-
Results from Monday and Tuesday games are not included.
-
First-place teams are listed as automatic qualifiers.
-
In the event of a tie, the AQ goes to the highest-rated team in the RPI.
-
For the 2022 season, 15 automatic qualifiers will be granted. No play-in games will take place in the 29-team field.
AUTOMATIC QUALIFIERS (15)
North Carolina ACC
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
1
|
4
|
4-0
|
1-0
|
5-0
|
—
|
Maryland Big Ten
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
2
|
7
|
2-0
|
2-0
|
5-1
|
—
|
Florida AAC
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
5
|
14
|
0-2
|
1-2
|
0-0
|
—
|
Denver Big East
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
9
|
28
|
0-1
|
0-0
|
3-0
|
Colorado (42)
|
Loyola Patriot League
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
10
|
27
|
1-0
|
0-1
|
2-0
|
—
|
Princeton Ivy League
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
11
|
20
|
0-1
|
0-2
|
2-0
|
—
|
Jacksonville ASUN
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
21
|
52
|
0-2
|
0-0
|
0-2
|
—
|
Stanford Pac-12
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
26
|
23
|
0-0
|
0-2
|
2-1
|
Colorado (42)
|
Saint Joseph's A-10
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
29
|
33
|
0-1
|
0-0
|
1-1
|
—
|
Fairfield MAAC
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
32
|
73
|
0-0
|
0-1
|
0-1
|
3 losses of 41+
|
Vermont America East
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
33
|
83
|
0-0
|
0-1
|
0-1
|
Binghamton (65)
|
Mercer Big South
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
34
|
84
|
0-2
|
0-0
|
0-1
|
High Point (47)
|
Drexel CAA
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
37
|
35
|
0-1
|
0-1
|
0-2
|
Penn (46)
|
Mount St. Mary's NEC
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
45
|
92
|
0-0
|
0-0
|
0-0
|
Bryant (64), La Salle (94)
|
Central Michigan MAC
RPI
|
SOS
|
1-5
|
6-10
|
11-20
|
41+L
|
74
|
101
|
0-0
|
0-0
|
0-2
|
5 losses of 41+
|
North Carolina will be the heavy favorite to lift the trophy at Homewood Field … Maryland is slated to move up to No. 2 in our projection after winning the Big Ten … Florida won the American once again in blowout fashion over Vanderbilt.
Denver needed a major comeback to avoid the upset to Georgetown and certainly saved one of the bubble teams’ seasons … Loyola handled its rival Navy well in the Patriot League final. The Greyhounds will probably be traveling to the No. 8 seed or be the No. 8 seed … Princeton prevented another bid thief by finishing off a perfect Ivy League season.
Jacksonville heads back to the tournament and likely to Gainesville for the first round … Stanford didn’t leave it up to the committee by completing the Pac-12 title chase. … Saint Joseph’s is projected to play James Madison at Rutgers, the current home of former Hawk attacker Stephanie Kelly.
Fairfield made sure that the MAAC champion will defend its title next year by defeating departing Monmouth … Welcome to the field, Vermont! The Catamounts came from behind to beat Albany in the America East final … Drexel took home the CAA title at home in overtime over Towson.
New conference, same result for Mercer, which won the Big South title by avenging a regular-season loss against High Point … Mount St. Mary’s squeaked past Bryant in a battle of two teams departing the NEC … Central Michigan romped past Robert Morris 20-10 to clinch the Chippewas first NCAA appearance.