“To be honest, I don’t really remember anybody trying to stick with me head-up,” Buchanan told the St. Louis Post-Dispatch earlier this week. “They usually just tried to use the stick skills and take the ball from me that way. But I don’t think anybody’s ever ‘manned’ me — man-to-manned me up in lacrosse.”
While Seidel was sure of Buchanan’s potential, Phillip “Flip” Naumberg was even more bullish on his prospects. Naumberg founded the Vail Lacrosse Shootout, invented the Rock-It-Pocket and led the Colorado State men’s club program, where Seidel played, to four national championships in 14 seasons. He visited St. Louis for a month each spring and helped Seidel coach the Red Devils.
Seidel said that Naumberg believed he could make Buchanan the best lacrosse player of all time. Buchanan, who rushed for 1,656 yards and 27 touchdowns in four seasons at Chaminade, possessed a strength and agility that reminded him of another crossover athlete.
Jim Brown.
"I've seen them all," Naumberg told Seidel. "I've seen Tim Goettelman. I've seen Gary [Gait]. But that guy [Buchanan] can dodge from X like nobody's business. We've just got to get him handles."
Naumberg died of a heart attack in May of 2018. He was 66. A couple weeks later Chaminade lost in the state quarterfinals. It was Buchanan’s last lacrosse game.
Afterwards Buchanan apologized to the rest of the team. He felt as though he could have done more to help lift them to the title.
“He left a lasting impression that you didn't do enough unless you win the state championship,” Seidel said.
During practices in the years since, Seidel will hear one of his players invoke the impassioned speech. “Remember what Kobi said,” they’ll say. The team’s intensity immediately ratchets up.
“He couldn't devote 270 a days a year [to lacrosse], but he gave us his heart for 90 days and you knew he wished he gave a couple more,” said Seidel, who grew up in Nyack, N.Y., ten miles south of West Point. “That's how the military academy kids are.”
On a Saturday in late September, Seidel took a break from prepping food at Prasino, a farm-to-table restaurant in St. Charles (Mo.) where he works as a chef, to refill his soda. Sure enough, on a TV nearby, he saw Buchanan in the backfield against Cincinnati.
Seidel ran back into the kitchen.
“Put on the game!” he texted his dad and a couple friends. While they’ll be tuned in this weekend and hope to see Army sing the alma mater second, Seidel still holds out hope that even if Buchanan moves up NFL draft boards, he’ll get another chance to shine on the lacrosse field.
He even emailed some highlight clips of Buchanan to Joe Alberici.
“I wanted to let him know that when he is done [playing] football he is just as good as everybody else at lacrosse,” Seidel said. “I would love to see something like that happen.”