In this hypothetical situation, there were moments of retributive (removing the player from the game), restorative (the player writing and delivering an apology letter) and procedural (the coaches working together on procedures and an action plan) justice once the wrong was acknowledged. The player who was taunted could maybe then heal better from the incident knowing that they received the apology and that the coaches were working together to put something in place to benefit all players. The dialogue that occurred on the field and afterwards allowed for action to take place in ways that made sense for that situation.
Even though that is a hypothetical scenario, I can imagine that you, the reader, have seen and/or heard some form of this from youth to high school to college to professional levels of play across sports. When I learn of incidents in the lacrosse community, it is challenging — whether the incident is based on race/ethnicity or not. However, I do get more hopeful as time progresses because people in the community are now more consistently acknowledging the wrongs that have occurred. I imagine and hope that the situations are followed by apologies, dialogue and action so that the necessary justice and healing can take place for each place. To do this takes a great deal of humility, ownership and patience.
Georgetown University with the legacy of the 272 does not have it all “figured out.” The lacrosse community does not have it all “figured out.” However, we are working to figure it out in ways that make sense for our respective situations and communities. Even though there are some standard things that can be done, each situation is different and requires different ways of navigating — especially if those involved are seeking to repair relationships through restorative justice practices (i.e. Georgetown working with the descendants of the 272).
It is also important to note that when an incident happens, people are never the same. Picture this: you have a piece of paper in your hand and ball it up. Carefully, you undo it and smooth it out as best as you can. However, the paper will never be smooth and flat like it was before. That’s how I view healing. Think about when you get a cut or a scrape. The body stops the bleeding, fights off potential infection, takes time to repair cells and you may have a scar left over. The cut or scrape may be healed, but there’s still a reminder that it was once there. Whether it’s a physical wound or one that is emotional, healing is necessary and does take time. We always remember the situations that required justice and healing in the first place, and we can move forward each time. But just like the paper, there will still be a fold or imprint that remains.
So, what now? I am hopeful that fewer incidents (race/ethnicity-based or otherwise) will occur moving forward. I am hopeful that justice will happen for the incidents that have already taken place and for the ones that have yet to occur. I am hopeful that healing will take place. Mostly, I hope that people take time to pause and ask themselves what type of justice is needed in a situation.
This way, we are better equipped to acknowledge, apologize, dialogue and take action moving forward.
Lauren Davenport is the manager of athlete development at US Lacrosse. She has coached lacrosse at the youth, high school and collegiate levels.