Unlike most of his classmates in his small class at EA, Zappala seemingly had his college plans locked up for nearly three full calendar years. When he saw his friends apply to prestigious schools across the country, though, it started to set his decision in motion.
"I think I started to realize it when my friends were talking about all of these great schools all over the country, and I started figuring out that there was more to college than just lacrosse," Zappala said. "I'm not saying that I picked the wrong school when I chose Maryland, but I didn't think of what my life would be like lacrosse. My friends were talking about future plans and I didn't have any other than lacrosse. I talked to my girlfriend about it and I realized I had to make my decision sooner rather than later."
Tillman took the devastating news in stride, telling Zappala that he always had a home as a Terp and later offering to meet up with him after a Maryland road trip to Philly. Zappala had to decline to get to class, but the support from Tillman stuck with him. It was a tough decision, but Zappala knew it was what he had to do.
"I definitely loved playing for EA. I had so much fun playing with my friends on the team. I loved the small community and playing for the team and for Coach Hayes and everyone around me," Zappala said. "But when it came to the end of that, I was ready to stop playing lacrosse. I think I knew beforehand that it would be the end of organized lacrosse for me."
"Some people asked me, 'are you mad?,' and I tell them, 'no, I love Curtis. I'm not going to like a guy more or less based on whether he wants to play," Tillman said. "I want these guys to make life whatever they want it to be. Some people didn't understand that, but Curtis doesn't owe us anything. He's on a journey through life. I give him a lot of credit because he didn't feel like he couldn't fully commit to playing. Each guy is different, but there's a lot of commitment that goes into being a part of a Division I athletic team."
Hayes admitted to being a little bit surprised when Zappala told him of his decision. At the same time, he saw Zappala mature over the course of the four varsity seasons that the two spent together, and as Zappala got older, Hayes saw changes in his star attackman.
"I think as he got older, he was conflicted about being put in a, 'I'm just a lacrosse player,' box," Hayes said. "He would have been an awesome college player, but he wanted other things in life. I supported him then and I support him now. Playing a college sport is a big decision, and you have to be fully invested in your decision."
Tillman echoed those sentiments. The Terps' boss has been around long enough to see just about everything happen off the field. Tillman had high expectations for Zappala's Maryland career, but also understands that the grind of Division I athletics isn't for everyone.
"He would have had to earn his way, but it goes without saying, he seemed to make a mark on every team that he played on," Tillman said. "There was no reason to believe that he wasn't going to do the same for us. Curtis wanted to do a lot of other things other than play lacrosse, and with how much kids play now, it's easy to get burned out. We're always going to love him because he's such a good kid and we think so highly of his family. That's what I'm bummed out about the most – that we don't have him around as a person, let alone a player."